Accident Or Negligence? What To Keep In Mind If You Have Suffered Traumatic Injuries

Falls and motor-vehicle crashes are the most common causes of traumatic injuries in the United States. Nearly 40% of patients discharged from Level 1 trauma centers have suffered either of the two.

Traumatic brain injury (TBI) alone results in approximately 230,000 hospitalizations a year; for 80,000 to 90,000 people the injury is so severe that they are placed on long-term disability. Another 40,000 hospitalizations are attributed to burn injuries while 30,000 traumatic amputations occur each year due to traffic-, workplace-, electrocution-, and other types of serious accidents.

Behind each statistic is a story. Sometimes, a spur-of-the-moment decision can lead to a life-altering injury. Sometimes, the accident could have been prevented if someone else — whether that’s one or more individuals, a small business, or even a large corporation — had taken a different action. Sometimes, the severity and extent of the injury is not immediately clear, such as with internal injuries and concussions. Some accidents create legal liability. But how do you know when another party can be held legally responsible for an accident?

When can you sue?

To better understand your rights, let’s discuss “negligence.” This legal concept ultimately determines if the accident you or a loved one suffered can lead to a lawsuit.

Serious car accident resulted in $3.5 million settlement

First of all, consider this real-world example. On the way from Chico, Calif., to Davis, Calif., five female coworkers suffered serious injuries when the driver lost control of the van in which they were traveling as a result of a tire de-treading. The van left the freeway, rolling on the dirt shoulder. Was the accident the consequence of bad luck or could negligence be established?

Stewart P. Galbraith of Penney & Associates represented the plaintiffs as a formal complaint was filed in Butte County against the tire manufacturer, the manufacturer of the van, and the tire dealership. After a three-day formal mediation hearing, the parties in this challenging product liability case eventually reached a $3.5-million settlement.

What does it take to establish negligence for traumatic injuries?

Every state is different but the general principles are as follows: In order to have grounds for a negligence claim, you need to establish that the liable party owed you a duty of care, breached said duty, and caused you damages in the process. There are four elements needed to prove negligence:

  1. Duty of care

    This means every person is obligated by law to be careful or act reasonably. For example, when you drive a car you have a duty to follow the rules of the road. If you own a building or property, it’s your duty to make sure it’s reasonably safe and free from hazards and dangerous defects. If you practice medicine, you have a duty to your patients to treat them in a careful manner and exercise the skills of a trained physician.

  2. Breach of duty

    Did you run a red light? Did you leave live wires exposed in your apartment building? Did you fail to abide by the Hippocratic Oath? Then you may be accused of breach of duty, which is a failure to act with reasonable care. Put differently, you have either done something that a reasonably careful person would not do — or you have failed to do something that a reasonably careful person would do.

  3. Causation

    Did the driver who ran a red light hit you? Then, you could establish that the failure to conform to the requisite duty of care caused you harm. In other words, if the breach of duty caused the accident, there will be legal liability. The causation doesn’t necessarily have to be direct; it can also be through proximate cause, which means the defendant was the primary cause of the injuries. For example, let’s say the defendant hit a telephone pole that fell on your house, causing the roof to cave in. If you were injured as a result, the defendant is the proximate cause.

  4. Actual Loss or Damages

    “Somebody could have been hurt” is not grounds for legal liability. As frightening as it is to experience a close call due to someone else’s behavior, a case for negligence must show the accident resulted in actual losses or damages. If you suffered an injury or other form of loss because of the defendant’s actions, you can prove negligence and seek compensation for the damages you suffered. A serious injury can further compound what you are owed.

The injury attorneys of Penney & Associates specialize in a broad range of these types of cases. We work with independent experts to corroborate your damage claims and disprove counterclaims made by those at fault, ensuring that when you do file your lawsuit, you will have all the information needed to win, backed by attorneys who understand the complexities of California’s personal injury laws. Contact us for a free consultation.

* This blog is not meant to dispense legal advice and is not a comprehensive review of the facts, the law, this topic or cases related to the topic. For a full review of our disclaimer and policies, please click here.

Woman on cell phone with man looking at accident in the background

What Is Uninsured and Underinsured Motorist Coverage on Your Insurance Policy?

When you're out on the road, you do everything you can to drive safely and protect yourself and your passengers. But what happens if you're involved in a car accident...
Person holding phone in front of steering wheel and texting

Distracted Driving: The Most Dangerous Cities for Pedestrians

The problem of pedestrians killed or seriously injured on California roadways is bad and growing worse. That’s a fact, according to the California Office of Traffic Safety (OTS). In this...
Military personnel looking at floor with hands together

Navigating PTSD Claims in California Personal Injury Law: What Victims Need to Know

According to the National Center for PTSD, about 6% of the U.S. population will experience this psychological condition at some point in their lives. When that condition is the consequence...