Volleyball Injury Due To Defective Product

Ayers v. Sports Imports Inc., Santa Barbara County Superior Court docket #1220316

On May 15, 2005, a 15 year old girl named Alexandra Ayers was participating in club volleyball at UC Santa Barbara’s Event Center when in the course of play jumped and landed on the base area of a portable referee stand, causing an anterior cruciate ligament rupture of the left knee among others. Plaintiff underwent numerous surgeries. Plaintiff claimed that she never fully recovered and as such lost a valuable scholarship to a major university. Plaintiff argued that she was considered one of the top 25 volleyball recruits in the country.

In sum, the plaintiff alleged that the sloping leg configuration of the referee stand was defective causing the stand to be in an area where players routinely land after spiking the ball. Plaintiff contended that UCSB was also negligent in that it replaced its old stands that did not protrude as much as the new referee stands. Defendant Sports Imports Inc. argued that it had never had any other reported injuries with this stand. Defendant UCSB argued that plaintiff’s parents had signed a waiver and release of liability and that the said stand was perfectly safe for its intended use.
The case settled for $295,000.00.

Penney and Associates handles all types of personal injury cases, including cases were individuals or their families have suffered serious injuries while at school due to the negligence of others. We cannot guarantee any outcome of your case that may or may not have similar facts to those noted above. Penney and Associates has offices throughout the state of California including Fairfield, Sacramento, Loomis, Roseville and Chico.

* This blog is not meant to dispense legal advice and is not a comprehensive review of the facts, the law, this topic or cases related to the topic. For a full review of our disclaimer and policies, please click here.

Are Hoverboards Safe? Beware of Fall & Fire Risks

Are Hoverboards Safe? Beware of Fall & Fire Risks

A hoverboard is a two-wheeled, battery-powered self-balancing scooter. Like skateboards and standard scooters, hoverboards can be a lot of fun. They aren’t the most practical way to get around town—even...
Are Electric Rideshare Scooters Safe?

Are Electric Rideshare Scooters Safe?

Electric scooters, or e-scooters, are one of the most popular ways to get around without a car, thanks to the convenience of app-based rental services, such as Lime, Spin, and...
Bike Safety: Tips for Riding Safe for Beginners

Bike Safety: Tips for Riding Safe for Beginners

In 2019, 846 bicyclists were killed in a traffic collision in the United States. A large portion of these fatalities could likely have been avoided if bikers and motorists rode...